• About
  • Contact
  • Submit News
Monday, June 5, 2023
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • World
    • Business
    • Economy
    • Politics
    • Geo-Engineering
    • Environment
    • Police State
    • Foreign Policy
  • U.S.
    • Federal Reserve
  • Globalist Agenda
    • Secret Societies
    • World Order
    • The Globalists
  • Health
    • Big Pharma
    • Fluoride
    • Food
    • Gmo’s
    • Vaccines
  • Sci/Tech
    • Space
    • Trans-Humanism
  • Media
    • Documentaries
    • Interviews
    • Talks/Lectures
  • More+
    • Ancient Civilizations
    • Astrology
    • Astrotheology
    • Awareness
    • DIY
    • Esoteric
    • Free Energy
    • Hidden History
    • Infographics
    • Knowledge
    • Religion
    • Spirituality
  • Home
  • World
    • Business
    • Economy
    • Politics
    • Geo-Engineering
    • Environment
    • Police State
    • Foreign Policy
  • U.S.
    • Federal Reserve
  • Globalist Agenda
    • Secret Societies
    • World Order
    • The Globalists
  • Health
    • Big Pharma
    • Fluoride
    • Food
    • Gmo’s
    • Vaccines
  • Sci/Tech
    • Space
    • Trans-Humanism
  • Media
    • Documentaries
    • Interviews
    • Talks/Lectures
  • More+
    • Ancient Civilizations
    • Astrology
    • Astrotheology
    • Awareness
    • DIY
    • Esoteric
    • Free Energy
    • Hidden History
    • Infographics
    • Knowledge
    • Religion
    • Spirituality
No Result
View All Result
The Global Elite
No Result
View All Result

TPP Leak Confirms the Worst: US Negotiators Still Trying to Trade Away Internet Freedoms

by Global Elite News
14 November, 2013
in World News
0
TPP Leak Confirms the Worst: US Negotiators Still Trying to Trade Away Internet Freedoms
FacebookTwitter

After years of secret trade negotiations over the future of intellectual property rights (and limits on those rights), the public gets a chance to looks at the results. For those of us who care about free speech and a balanced intellectual property system that encourages innovation, creativity, and access to knowledge, it’s not a pretty picture.

Today Wikileaks published a complete draft of the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) agreement’s chapter on “intellectual property rights.” The leaked text, from August 2013, confirms long-standing suspicions about the harm the agreement could do to users’ rights and a free and open Internet. From locking in excessive copyright term limits to further entrenching failed policies that give legal teeth to Digital Rights Management (DRM) tools, the TPP text we’ve seen today reflects a terrible but unsurprising truth: an agreement negotiated in near-total secrecy, including corporations but excluding the public, comes out as an anti-user wish list of industry-friendly policies.

Despite the Obama administration’s top U.S. negotiators’ fast approaching their self-imposed 2013 deadline to complete the agreement, today’s leak is the public’s first look at the sprawling text since a February 2011 leak [pdf] of the same chapter and a July 2012 leak of an individual section. And even as the public has been completely shut out, the U.S. Trade Representative has lobbied for wider latitude to negotiate and for “fast-track authority” to bypass Congressional review.

The document Wikileaks has published contains nearly 100 pages of bracketed text—meaning it includes annotated sections that are proposed and opposed by the negotiating countries. The text is not final, but the story it tells so far is unmistakable: United States negotiators (with occasional help from others) repeatedly pushing for restrictive policies, and facing only limited opposition, coming from countries like Chile, Canada, New Zealand, and Malaysia.

Copyright Terms

The leaked chapter features proposals for setting a new “floor” for copyright duration, ranging from the already problematic U.S. term of life of the author plus 70 years to an incredible life of the author plus 100 years, proposed by Mexico. Such bloated term lengths benefit only a vanishingly small portion of available works, and impoverish the public domain of our collective history. The U.S. is also pushing for countries to embrace terms lengths of 95 years for corporate and 120 years for unpublished works.

Extending term lengths in the U.S. was already a bad idea. The U.S. Trade Rep shouldn’t be compounding it by forcing other countries to follow suit. Countries around the world that have shorter term lengths than the U.S. celebrate the arrival each year of new works into the public domain, and the economic activity that can accompany them. Since the 1998 passage of the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act, however, the U.S. will see no new published works enter the public domain until 2019. The proposal in TPP would export that sort of restriction to all the countries that join it.

These expansive terms have also exacerbated the widely recognized problem of “orphan works” also known as “hostage works.” These are works where the rightsholder can’t be identified or located and, therefore, folks are afraid to use them, publish them online, etc, lest the rightsholder appear at last and file a lawsuit. As a result, millions of works effectively disappear from the cultural commons until their copyright terms at long last expire. Earlier this year, the U.S. Register of Copyrights advised a reduction or limitation in term length as a possible solution. Crystallizing U.S. term lengths in international agreements would frustrate efforts to enact such reasonable policies. This is a classic example of policy laundering, whereby corporate interests use secretive international forums to trump the democratic process at the national level.

Fair Use and Fair Dealing

Although the addition of the “3-step test” for fair use provisions was hailed by the U.S. Trade Representative as a major step forward for users’ rights in trade agreements, its original intention has been subverted. It now may serve as a ceiling on rights, and not a floor.

The agreement claims not to confine copyright limitations and exceptions further than earlier deals, such as the Berne Convention, but early analysis from groups like Knowledge Ecology International (KEI) suggests that’s not the case. Functionally, TPP as drafted creates a tightly circumscribed space in which countries can grant rights like fair use and fair dealing to its citizens.

Given the important role that flexibility in copyright has played in enabling innovation and free speech, it’s a terrible idea to restrict that flexibility in a trade agreement.

Intermediary liability

The newly leaked text reveals substantial disagreement over the language on copyright liability for Internet Service Providers (ISPs) and other online platforms. The February 2011 leak contained extensive language that would have imposed regulatory requirements to police users’ activities online and paved the way for systems like three-strikes take down policies and ISPs filtering and blocking access to websites that allegedly infringe or facilitate copyright infringement.

Even though the text appears to be very much in flux, it’s clear from the leaked chapter that Canada is pushing back hard against U.S. pressure to adopt draconian copyright enforcement measures. A majority of countries appear to be proposing language that would give them some flexibility to limit the liability of ISPs, so they can develop enforcement frameworks that best suit their national laws and priorities. That flexibility is essential to staving off copyright enforcement laws that in practice would violate users’ free speech and privacy. And yet the U.S., backed by Australia, opposes this language.

Anti-Circumvention

The leaked draft includes controversial language calling for laws prohibiting the circumvention of “technological protection measures,” also known as DRM. The U.S. has had such a law in place for over 15 years, and it’s been a disaster for free speech and competition, chilling the legitimate speech of innovators, filmmakers, security researchers, and many others. In fact, it’s so bad that President Obama and many in Congress have said it must be reformed. Just as much of the U.S. public is realizing our anti-circumvention law was a mistake in the first place, we’re not only trying to export it but also potentially impeding our own ability to fix it.

Despite numerous heroic proposals for fixes, most notably from Canada and Chile, the articles as drafted include many such dangerous provisions. Though the text remains unsettled, the current proposal calls for criminal liability for violations of these anti-circumvention provisions, except for when conducted by a non-profit.

Worse, because of the broad language, this criminal liability could apply to people circumventing these restrictions even where the underlying work is not covered by copyright.

Temporary Copies

The strict regulation of temporary copies reflected in the February 2011 leak was a startling throwback to an outmoded and dangerous idea: that copyright should apply even to ephemeral copies. The implications are staggering. Computers and networks create, in the normal course of operation, temporary and ephemeral copies. Regulations on these sorts of copies, as described in the earlier leak, would interfere with basic technical operations and give rightsholders an opportunity to sit on an essential chokepoint of the Internet.

Fortunately, negotiators may have recognized the fundamental folly of this proposal. Although the U.S. has yet to support any reasonable text on this topic, the draft leaked today included a proposed clarification that temporary copies may be exempted from copyright restrictions. Language from Chile, New Zealand, and Malaysia proposes that countries may make these exemptions for:

temporary acts of reproduction which are transient or incidental and an integral and essential part of a technological process and whose sole purpose is to enable (a) a lawful transmission in a network between third parties by an intermediary; or (b) a lawful use of a work; and which have no independent economic significance.

Similar language appears in a footnote proposed by a larger group of countries that does not include the U.S., and which negotiators have noted faces “no substantive objection to the concept” but which is not yet finalized.

Patents

The leaked draft reveals that the US is pushing hard for provisions expanding the reach of patent law and limiting ways in which a patent may be revoked. These proposals are meeting widespread opposition from the other participants. For example, the U.S. proposes—and nearly every other nation opposes—that patents be made available for inventions that are “plants and animals.”

The U.S. also proposes language that would prohibit denying “a patent solely on the basis that the product did not result in enhanced efficacy of the known product.” Again, nearly every other nation opposes the U.S. on this issue. And a good thing too. Setting the bar to patentability too low locks up innovation. Advocates for access to medicine argue that it allows pharmaceutical companies delay generic entry through “evergreening.” In other technology areas, the U.S. is seeing the terrible consequences of a flood of low-quality software patents, many of which are for minor improvements on existing technology. There’s no reason for an international treaty to export the problems of the U.S. patent regime.

Conclusion

The latest TPP leak confirms our longstanding fears about these negotiations. The USTR is pushing for regulations that would, for the most part, put the desires of major content and patent owners over the needs of the public. No wonder the negotiators want to keep the process secret. There are marginal improvements since February 2011, but they are not enough. Real and substantially balanced proposals will not happen unless and until negotiators can be held accountable to the public for the proposals they are making.

Rest assured: if they can’t be challenged now, they will surely be challenged later. Internet users have proven that they will not stand for backroom deals that put their freedoms at risk.

Source: Electronic Frontier Foundation

tpp free trade internet

0 0 votes
Article Rating

21.7k
SHARES
FacebookTwitterSubscribe
PinterestTumblrLinkedin Reddit DiggStumbleupon PocketVkDeliciousBufferWeiboWhatsappXingFlattrMailPrint
Subscribe to Blog via Email
Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
Email Address Subscribe
Tags: free speechIntellectual PropertyInternationalTPPTrans-Pacific Partnership Agreement
Previous Post

Over 3,200 US prisoners serving life sentences for non-violent offenses including shoplifting – report

Next Post

Quantum physics proves that there IS an afterlife, claims scientist

Global Elite News

Your Source for Alternative News and Information. Deep Independent Journalism About Who Really Controls The World.

Related Posts

TPP Deal Just Signed: Paves Way for Authoritarian Technocracy
Technocracy

TPP Deal Just Signed: Paves Way for Authoritarian Technocracy

by TGE News
5 February, 2016
599
US, Japan, Canada, Australia and 8 Other Countries Sign Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement
World News

US, Japan, Canada, Australia and 8 Other Countries Sign Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement

by TGE News
4 February, 2016
302
The (TPP) Would Be The Most Important Step Toward A One World Economic System
Economics

The (TPP) Would Be The Most Important Step Toward A One World Economic System

by TGE News
13 November, 2014
93
Canada criminalizes criticism of Israel: Analyst
World News

Canada criminalizes criticism of Israel: Analyst

by Global Elite News
12 April, 2014
29
State of the Union 2014: Obama said what?
Politics

State of the Union 2014: Obama said what?

by Global Elite News
29 January, 2014
29
Kim Dotcom: the TPP ‘proves’ that Wall St and Hollywood own Obama
Politics

Kim Dotcom: the TPP ‘proves’ that Wall St and Hollywood own Obama

by Global Elite News
26 November, 2013
51
If gun control passes, there will come ‘free speech control’ and the government banning of websites, books and art
Knowledge

If gun control passes, there will come ‘free speech control’ and the government banning of websites, books and art

by Global Elite News
18 March, 2013
16
What is the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPP)?
Knowledge

What is the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPP)?

by Global Elite News
13 March, 2013
91
Load More
Next Post
Quantum physics proves that there IS an afterlife, claims scientist

Quantum physics proves that there IS an afterlife, claims scientist

Transforming America’s Schools into Authoritarian Instruments of Compliance

Transforming America’s Schools into Authoritarian Instruments of Compliance

Subscribe
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
A List of Banks Owned by the Rothschild Dynasty

A List of Banks Owned by the Rothschild Dynasty

19 February, 2013

The History of the ‘House of Rothschild’ (Complete)

24 January, 2013
Wikileaks Is A Rothschild Operation

Wikileaks Is A Rothschild Operation

22 December, 2012
Secrets Of The Elite: Why Forbes’s Rich List Doesn’t Include The Wealthiest Families On The Planet

Secrets Of The Elite: Why Forbes’s Rich List Doesn’t Include The Wealthiest Families On The Planet

19 September, 2015
The Act Of 1871 – America Incorporated

The Act Of 1871 – America Incorporated

22
Wikileaks Is A Rothschild Operation

Wikileaks Is A Rothschild Operation

6
The Rothschilds Purchased Jerusalem in 1829

The Rothschilds Purchased Jerusalem in 1829

5
Who Controls the Money Supply Controls the World

Who Controls the Money Supply Controls the World

4
David Straight: Awakening Seminar

David Straight: Awakening Seminar

20 August, 2022
The Man Who Knew Too Much (Documentary)

The Man Who Knew Too Much (Documentary)

14 November, 2021
The Puppet Masters Portfolios

The Puppet Masters Portfolios

5 August, 2021
Michael Tellinger: Hidden Origins of Humanity

Michael Tellinger: Hidden Origins of Humanity

29 July, 2021

Connect With Us

Most Read

  • A List of Banks Owned by the Rothschild Dynasty

    A List of Banks Owned by the Rothschild Dynasty

    7 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The History of the ‘House of Rothschild’ (Complete)

    100 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Wikileaks Is A Rothschild Operation

    4 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Secrets Of The Elite: Why Forbes’s Rich List Doesn’t Include The Wealthiest Families On The Planet

    2 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • George Soros Exposed as a Rothschild Agent in the 1990’s

    2 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Categories

Newsletter

Enter your email address to subscribe to our newsletter and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 12,353 other subscribers

Latest Posts

  • David Straight: Awakening Seminar
  • The Man Who Knew Too Much (Documentary)
  • The Puppet Masters Portfolios
  • Michael Tellinger: Hidden Origins of Humanity

Site Links

  • Donate
  • Resources
  • Sitemap
  • The Globalists

About Us

TGE news is here to bring you documented facts on what’s really happening in the world that you will not see in the corporate media.

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy & Terms
  • Submit News

(OA) 2012-2023 TGE News

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • World
    • Business
    • Economy
    • Politics
    • Geo-Engineering
    • Environment
    • Police State
    • Foreign Policy
  • U.S.
    • Federal Reserve
  • Globalist Agenda
    • Secret Societies
    • World Order
    • The Globalists
  • Health
    • Big Pharma
    • Fluoride
    • Food
    • Gmo’s
    • Vaccines
  • Sci/Tech
    • Space
    • Trans-Humanism
  • Media
    • Documentaries
    • Interviews
    • Talks/Lectures
  • More+
    • Ancient Civilizations
    • Astrology
    • Astrotheology
    • Awareness
    • DIY
    • Esoteric
    • Free Energy
    • Hidden History
    • Infographics
    • Knowledge
    • Religion
    • Spirituality

(OA) 2012-2023 TGE News

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

0
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x
| Reply
 

Loading Comments...